Skip to main content

Scale Might Lie

A while back, the Mild Wife and I decided to get a fancy shmancy smart scale (something like this). We both like to keep an eye on our health, and the scale is one of those numbers that provides some hints about general health. Sure, the actual weight number can be misleading, but that's where a smart scale fills in some of the gaps. If you measure both your overall weight and your fat percentage, you've got a decent picture of what's happening with your body.

Now, we both know that the numbers aren't supposed to be completely accurate. However, so long as they're consistent, you can make deductions about how your diet and exercise are treating your body. Let's say the scale consistently says that you're five pounds heavier than you actually are. That's nice, but it's the same five pounds every single day. If my weight is lower on a Tuesday than on a Monday, that still means I lost some weight.

So far, the scale has proven useful, but I get a big kick out of it for a couple of reasons. First of all, ours let us configure the units. I immediately chose the metric system, so my weight is reported in kilograms instead of pounds. Sure, it means a bit of mental math to get back to the number I am familiar with, but ever since the Montreal trip, I am convinced that the metric system is superior. It's a simple reason, really: my brain understands how cold -4 degrees Celsius is much faster than it does 24 degrees Fahrenheit (the numbers are slightly off, but you get the idea). In fact, I now have a decent gauge of how many kilograms I am supposed to weigh.

The second, and far more amusing, reason, is that the numbers that the scale report for me are weird as all heck. There have been some days where I have been very sedentary, but I have still managed to lose half a kilo of fat and pack on half a kilo of muscle. There have been days where I've eaten fairly well and exercised, but the numbers barely moved. This has led to all sorts of theories about what could cause these discrepancies, and the explanations have gotten progressively funnier.

The first concern was that the scale was broken or off somehow, but the Mild Wife's numbers all make sense. The scale itself seems to be working, as best as we can tell. It just happens to report funky numbers for me. The next theory was that I needed to change my protein intake, but after playing with some of that, the numbers seem to be up and down again. Ultimately, I don't think the fluctuations have that much to do with whether I'm consuming much protein or not.

That led us to my favorite of explanation of all: I'm stepping on the scale wrong. At one point, the Mild Wife even watched me step on the scale to make sure I wasn't somehow leaving part of of my foot off the scale or otherwise messing up the measurement. I was not, and she was satisfied with how I stepped on the scale. I still saw some odd fluctuations, though.

Ultimately, I think I've decided that I'm not going to worry that much about day-to-day changes, but focus on the long-term trends. So long as my body fat is going down, my muscle mass is staying constant or going up, and the percentage of water is staying about the same, I'm good. Even if that means the scale tells me I've gained two or three kilos in the process, I'm fine with that.

Incidentally, I did find one article that had some potential explanations for the weight fluctuations, but I'm not entirely sure how much of that applies to me. Either way, it gives me some clues about what might be happening. It's still not as funny as the idea that I'm stepping on the scale incorrectly, though.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

All Good Things ...

August 8, 2009. Over twelve years ago, I started blogging with this simple post . I didn't really have a great reason for starting the blog, other than I wanted to try it out. I wanted to try writing and putting it where others could read it. I don't know, it just seemed like a new adventure to try. Along the way, there have been all sorts of posts and all sorts of life events, but through it all, I kept writing. It just became a part of what I do at some point. It wasn't a matter of whether I was going to write a blog post, it was a matter of when. The Mild Wife has described it as a "writing practice," and it was one of the reasons why I kept writing. Honestly, it's good practice, and it gives me an opportunity to hone my craft. I'm no professional author, but we all have to write stuff in our everyday lives. Why not give yourself reps to get better at it? However, I think it's time for that practice to change. My weekly anecdotes sure kept me amused...

Dreams

Normally, I don't eat very many sweets. I tend to eat pretty generous portions, but I generally prefer savory food over sweet. In fact, I usually prefer things half as sweet when possible. My preference doesn't have anything to do with health reasons, it's just one of those things that I've always liked better. That said, I do inevitably eat dessert, particularly if I'm out with other people. My stance towards dessert is roughly equivalent to those who are social drinkers . If other people want to munch on something for dessert, I'm not about to cross my arms and refuse. That'd be just a tad gauche. So, I do eat some dessert. I even have a few standby favorites that I'll usually order when presented with them (brownies, creme brulee, and apple pie). But left to my own devices, I'm not about to go hunting for dessert. Apparently, this means that the sugar can really mess with my system under the right circumstances. As I've discovered, ...

New York City Trip (Day 1)

After my crappy flight , I was now in Newark, New Jersey at 7AM on a Friday morning. I had done a little bit of reading up, so I knew which bus I needed to take and where I was going to get off. All in all, getting into the city was surprisingly easy. I suppose speaking the language does make things simpler. Through no real planning of mine (a theme of the trip, at least on my part), I picked one of the later bus stops at which to get off, Grand Central. I actually just figured that getting off at Grand Central would give me options, and heck, it's called Grand Central. That just screamed "decent place to disembark that might be close to some stuff" to me, so that's where I got off. However, it also meant that we drove down 42 nd St to get to my bus stop. That just happens to be a big street, and it gave me a glimpse of Times Square as we drove by. My bus stop choice had accidentally given me a rough layout of the city. Go me. I had about 6 hours to kill...